Homestyle Potato Salad Classic Flavor for Any Meal

Homestyle Potato Salad
220 cal
3.95

The Jimmy John’s Homestyle Potato Salad is the perfect balance of creamy comfort and fresh ingredients. Loved by customers of all ages, this classic side is ideal for single lunches, boxed meals, or large catering events.

With tender, perfectly cooked potatoes, rich mayonnaise, and a blend of herbs and seasoning, this salad brings nostalgic homestyle flavor to every bite. Whether paired with a Big John® sandwich for a quick lunch or served in a catering platter for 50 guests, it’s a side dish that satisfies both taste buds and event planners.

Jimmy John’s Homestyle Potato Salad stands out for its classic, comforting taste and versatility. Unlike typical deli sides, it is prepared fresh daily with quality ingredients, making it a favorite for office meals, corporate events, and personal lunches.

Each batch features:

  • Tender, diced potatoes — cooked to perfect softness without being mushy
  • Creamy mayonnaise — provides richness and smooth texture
  • Chopped celery and onions — add crunch and flavor depth
  • Herbs and seasonings — a subtle blend of dill, paprika, and black pepper for classic taste

Every ingredient is chosen for freshness and consistency, ensuring the salad tastes the same whether it’s a single serving or a large catering bowl.

The homestyle potato salad delivers:

  • Creamy base from mayonnaise
  • Savory notes from celery and onion
  • Herbal freshness from dill and seasoning
  • Light, satisfying taste that pairs well with sandwiches, wraps, or grilled meats

Its flavor is designed to compliment any Jimmy John’s sandwich without overpowering the main course, making it a trusted catering side for both small and large events.

  • Single Lunches: Enjoy it with a sandwich and drink for a classic lunch combo
  • Box Lunches: Perfect for individually packed meals at office meetings
  • Catering Platters: Serves as a creamy, crowd-pleasing side for large groups
  • Party Buffets: Adds color, flavor, and texture to the event table

No matter the occasion, the Homestyle Potato Salad fits seamlessly into balanced meals, offering both comfort and freshness.

Here is the nutritional information for Jimmy John’s Homestyle Potato Salad per serving. Please note that nutritional values can vary slightly based on serving size and preparation methods.

Chol 20mg

Fat 14g

Carbo 17g

Protein 6g

  • Potatoes: Rich in potassium and vitamin C, providing energy and nutrients
  • Mayonnaise & Healthy Fats: Adds creaminess and satisfies appetite without heaviness
  • Vegetables: Celery and onion add fiber, crunch, and antioxidants
  • Portion-Controlled: Ideal for office lunches and catering boxes

The combination of comfort and nutrition makes it a smart choice for corporate catering menus, balancing indulgence with health-conscious appeal.

Here’s the ingredient list for Jimmy John’s Homestyle Potato Salad, and the above ingredients are based on publicly available information and popular copycat recipes. Ingredient offerings may vary by location

ComponentIngredients
BasePotatoes
ProteinHard-boiled eggs
VegetablesCelery
Herbs & SeasoningsDill
DressingMayonnaise-based dressing

The Homestyle Potato Salad contains several allergens, including egg (in mayonnaise), mustard, and potential soy (in processed ingredients). While primarily made with potatoes, onions, and celery, the dressing includes common allergens that customers should be aware of before ordering.

  • Egg-based (mayonnaise is a primary ingredient)
  • Mustard included in seasoning (contains mustard seed)
  • Potential soy (in preservatives or stabilizers)
  • Gluten-free ingredients, but cross-contact with wheat is possible

Calorie Burn Through Exercise refers to the amount of physical activity required to burn off a specific number of calories. Different exercises burn calories at different rates based on intensity and duration. This concept helps individuals understand how much exercise is needed to offset calorie intake such as For a 70 kg (155 lbs) person, here’s how many minutes it takes to burn 220 calories from Homestyle Potato Salad at Jimmy John’s:

Walking 51 minutes

Cycling 22 minutes

Running 18 minutes

Swimming 20 minutes

Creamy side dish with soft potatoes, hard-boiled egg, celery, dill, and a spiced dressing. Pairs with sandwiches or serves as a standalone side.

~220 calories per serving (small container, ~1/3 cup).

  • Fat: 14g (Saturated: ~2g)
  • Carbs: 17g (Net: ~15g)
  • Protein: 6g
  • Sodium: ~400-500mg

Egg (hard-boiled egg, possible in dressing), milk (possible in dressing), soy (possible in dressing). No fish, peanuts, sesame, shellfish, wheat in base form. Cross-contamination possible.

Vegetarian (egg, possible dairy). Not vegan due to egg and potential dairy in dressing. No vegan substitute available.

Yes! You can enjoy a single cup alongside your favorite sandwich for lunch. It’s perfect for individual meals or boxed lunches, offering a fresh and creamy side without the need for a full catering order.

A small bowl typically serves 5–8 guests, making it ideal for small office meetings or team lunches. Medium and large bowls are available for larger gatherings, serving 10–15 and 20–25 people, respectively.

Yes, it is vegetarian-friendly, containing no meat or animal-based broths. However, it does include eggs in mayonnaise, so those with egg allergies should exercise caution.

Absolutely. The Homestyle Potato Salad is a popular addition to corporate catering bundles, including Party Boxes, Box Lunches, and sandwich platters. Its classic flavor and creamy texture make it a staple side for large events.

The salad should be kept refrigerated and is best consumed within 24–36 hours. For catering events, it can safely sit chilled for up to 2 hours during service without compromising taste or texture.

Yes, the potatoes themselves are naturally gluten-free. The salad contains eggs and mayonnaise, so it may not suit those with egg allergies. Always check with your local Jimmy John’s location for cross-contact precautions.

It offers affordable per-person pricing, wide appeal, easy portioning, and simple serving. The creamy, classic flavor complements sandwiches and wraps, making it a reliable choice for office lunches and corporate events.

Yes. You can request extra herbs, lighter mayo, or additional vegetables for catering orders. Customization ensures the salad fits your event’s taste preferences and dietary needs.

Related post