Jimmy John’s Variety Cookie a Sweet Finale to Every Meal

Variety Cookie
410 cal
1.00

When it comes to perfecting a catering menu, few things delight guests more than a platter of fresh, warm, and irresistibly chewy cookies. Jimmy John’s Variety Cookie isn’t just dessert it’s the grand finale your event deserves. Crafted with care and baked fresh daily, these cookies combine premium ingredients, nostalgic flavor, and unmatched freshness that make every bite unforgettable.

Whether you’re hosting a corporate lunch, planning a holiday celebration, or simply rewarding your team after a successful week, Jimmy John’s dessert catering delivers the right balance of sweetness, quality, and convenience. The Variety Cookie box is more than just a treat it’s a thoughtful touch that elevates every event from good to great. Jimmy Johns Red Velvet Cookie contains 410 calories, 19 grams of fat and 58 grams of carbohydrates.

Desserts can be delicious and mindful. The Jimmy John’s Variety Cookie Box offers indulgence with portion-aware sizes and transparent nutrition info.

Chol 72mg

Fat 23g

Carbo 37 g

Protein 7 g

Food satisfies hunger, but dessert satisfies the heart. After the savory balance of Jimmy John’s famous sandwiches, sides, and drinks, dessert is what seals the memory of your meal.

  • Desserts bring joy: They symbolize comfort, togetherness, and celebration.
  • Cookies are universal: From kids’ parties to boardroom meetings, cookies bridge generations and preferences.
  • Balance & satisfaction: Adding dessert to catering ensures a complete dining experience sweet and savory in harmony.

It’s no surprise that companies booking Jimmy John’s catering bundles often add the Variety Cookie tray to their orders. It adds color, aroma, and texture elements that make a catered meal feel more premium and personal.

The Jimmy John’s Variety Cookie Box is a curated mix of the brand’s most loved cookies:

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie (410 cal): Classic, buttery, packed with semi-sweet chocolate chunks.
  • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie (370 cal): Comforting, wholesome, and perfect with coffee or tea.
  • Lemon Sunshine Cookie (420 cal): A bright, zesty option for those who love a citrusy finish.
  • Fudge Chocolate Brownie (optional add-on): Rich, dense, and chocolate-lover approved.

Each box contains an assortment of available flavors, giving every guest something to love.

Pro Tip: When ordering for larger groups, Jimmy John’s recommends one cookie per guest. For dessert lovers or longer events, ordering an additional box ensures everyone gets seconds

Jimmy John’s Variety Cookie is designed for flexibility. Whether you’re catering for ten or a hundred, this dessert option complements any occasion:

Event TypeWhy It Works
Corporate MeetingsSweet morale booster that pairs perfectly with box lunches.
Birthday PartiesVariety ensures everyone finds a favorite.
Holiday GatheringsAdd festive flavor to seasonal celebrations like Thanksgiving, Halloween, or Christmas.
Team CelebrationsSimple yet indulgent treat to thank your crew.
Community & School EventsIndividually portioned for easy serving and sharing.

Fun Fact: Many companies use Jimmy John’s cookies for employee appreciation days or corporate gifting, wrapped individually for easy distribution.

There’s real psychology behind why desserts and cookies, in particular leave such a lasting impression after a meal. Research in food science shows that ending a meal with sweetness triggers the brain’s “reward center,” increasing serotonin levels and improving overall satisfaction.

When paired with savory foods, cookies provide flavor balance and emotional comfort, making the meal feel complete. That’s why many event planners insist on including Jimmy John’s Variety Cookies in every corporate catering order.

Jimmy John’s understands this connection every cookie is baked to the perfect balance of sweetness, chew, and crunch, ensuring it complements the catering menu seamlessly.

​Here’s the ingredient list for Jimmy John’s Variety Cookie, presented in a 2-column table and the above ingredients are based on publicly available information and popular copycat recipes. Ingredient offerings may vary by location

ComponentIngredients
BaseFlour, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Butter, Eggs
Chocolate ChipsSemi-sweet chocolate chips (may include milk, dark, and white chocolate)
Leavening AgentsBaking soda
FlavoringsVanilla extract, Salt
  • Unbleached wheat flour for natural flavor and texture.
  • Pure butter and eggs to create richness and a soft, chewy bite.
  • Semi-sweet chocolate chunks sourced for smooth melt and deep cocoa flavor.
  • Real oats and raisins for wholesome fiber content.
  • Natural lemon extract to bring brightness and zest.
  • No trans fats or hydrogenated oils.

The Variety Cookies may contain the following allergens, depending on flavor

  • Wheat (in all cookie bases)
  • Milk (in butter, chocolate, or cream fillings)
  • Eggs (in most cookie dough)
  • Soy (in chocolate or lecithin)
  • Tree Nuts (in some varieties like macadamia or almond)
  • Peanuts (possible in certain flavors or cross-contact)

Calorie Burn Through Exercise refers to the amount of physical activity required to burn off a specific number of calories. Different exercises burn calories at different rates based on intensity and duration. This concept helps individuals understand how much exercise is needed to offset calorie intake such as ​For a 70 kg (155 lbs) individual, consuming a Variety Cookie from Jimmy John’s, which contains 410 calories, would require the following durations of various exercises to burn off the calories:

Walking 114 minutes

Cycling 63 minutes

Running 47 minutes

Swimming 34 minutes

rotating selection of 3-4 freshly baked cookies, usually including:

  • Chocolate Chip (classic)
  • White Chocolate Macadamia (fan favorite)
  • Oatmeal Raisin (sometimes seasonal)
  • Double Chocolate (rich & fudgy)

Dessert cookies in three flavors: Chocolate Chip (soft, gooey), Oatmeal Raisin (chewy, hearty), and Pumpkin White Chocolate (seasonal, pumpkin-spiced, introduced Aug 2024). Perfect after sandwiches.

Egg, gluten, milk, soy, wheat in all cookies. May contain peanuts, tree nuts due to shared equipment. No fish, sesame, shellfish. Cross-contamination possible.

Not customizable (pre-baked). Can request fresh cookies at some locations (subject to baking schedule) or pair with milk or coffee for a dessert combo.

Yes, available in catering trays (e.g., 12 cookies, ~$24-$30, varies). Contact local store or order via Jimmy John’s website for events. Day-old cookies sometimes sold at discount (~$1).

Each box includes a rotating selection of the brand’s best cookies Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, and Lemon Sunshine depending on store availability. Some locations may also include a Fudge Brownie option as a seasonal treat.

Yes, you can customize your Variety Cookie order by contacting your local Jimmy John’s catering manager. While availability may vary, stores often accommodate requests for specific mixes like “half chocolate chip, half oatmeal raisin.”

Cookies are baked daily and stay soft and flavorful for 24–36 hours when stored in a sealed container. For best freshness, store at room temperature and avoid refrigeration, which can dry them out.

Most cookies, like the Chocolate Chip and Oatmeal Raisin, do not contain nuts, but they are baked in facilities that handle nuts. Jimmy John’s includes allergen labels on packaging, so always review before serving to large groups.

When placing your catering order online or by phone, simply add the Variety Cookie Box under the “Desserts” section. You can choose the number of boxes based on your headcount, and the system calculates the total automatically.

Yes most locations offer individually wrapped cookies for safety, hygiene, and convenience. This makes them ideal for corporate lunches, picnics, or classroom events where self-service isn’t preferred.

Yes the cookies are a kid favorite, especially the Chocolate Chip and Lemon Sunshine. Their portion sizes are ideal for children’s parties, school events, and youth sports team snacks.

Related post

  • Lemon Sunshine Cookie

    Lemon Sunshine Cookie Lemon Sunshine Cookie Jimmy John’s Lemon Sunshine Cookie is a refreshing twist on the classic cookie, bursting with bold citrus flavor and a sweet, zesty finish. Soft-baked to perfection, each cookie features a golden-yellow hue with lightly crisp edges and a moist, chewy center that melts in your mouth. A delicate dusting…